CRIMINALIZING THE BREACHES OF THE CARDINAL PRINCIPLES OF HUMANITARIAN LAW AND THE REBIRTH OF INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL LAW Presentation of Lyne Calder, Giulia.

Slides:



Advertisements
Présentations similaires
Les pronoms compléments
Advertisements

Click to edit Master title style Soccuper de notre personnel Investir dans leur développement professionnel Leur donner confiance en lavenir Look after.
GERPISA Eleventh International Colloquium June 11-13, 2003 Paris The Origins and the Limits of the Productive Models Diversity Research questions and research.

1 Deepening the EU Sophie, Melita, Claudia, Tuulia, Pia, Ana, Lucas-Louis, Daniel, Daniela, Maria Alessandra.
The European works councils Group 1 PED as 4a.
Council of Europe Seminar on Counterfeit Medicines September 05 1 Aim of the seminar Is there a problem? Yes Do we need action?Yes Is there commitment?Yes.
Inforoute Santé du Canada Les défis de linteropérabilité en e-santé Mike Sheridan, Chef de lexploitation 19 mai 2006.
Harmonisation du cadre légal sur la cybercriminalité en Afrique Conditions pour laction judiciaire contre la cybercriminalité Rabat, juillet 2010.
Cliquez et modifiez le titre Cliquez pour modifier les styles du texte du masque Deuxième niveau Troisième niveau Quatrième niveau Cinquième niveau 1 Regulation.
Cliquez et modifiez le titre Cliquez pour modifier les styles du texte du masque Deuxième niveau Troisième niveau Quatrième niveau Cinquième niveau 23/01/2014©
Tbilisi – November 27, 2007 FAO / EBRD COOPERATION PROGRAMME ______ PROTECTION OF GEORGIAN WINE APPELLATIONS.
RECOMMENDATIONS ON EXPORT MARKETING FOR GEORGIAN WINES Tbilisi – November 27, 2007.
1 Initiatives involving the social partners in Europe on climate change and employment policies Denmark : The experience of the Lindoe Offshore Renewable.
Partenaires dITER Joint implementation Agreement Chine Corée du Sud Etats-Unis Fédération de Russie Japon Union Européenne + Inde Pays hôte dimplantation.
Réseau des Tribunaux référents Network of Pilot Courts 5. Quels indicateurs pour mesurer la qualité de la justice? Which indicators for measuring the quality.
Formal/Theory Phenomenology/Ex periments chaos break-up, giant-resonances, fusion interdisciplinarity (clusters, bose) mean-field (as a general theory)
Loi canadienne de mise en œuvre du Statut de Rome
5 Contractions Les normes: Communication 1.1 – Understanding the spoken and written language Comparisons 4.1 – Understanding the nature of language through.
Chapitre 5 Structure. Aller The verb aller (to go) is an irregular verb. Study the following forms. ALLER vais vas j tu il/elle/onva nous allons vous.
Les pluriels Sometimes you cant just take one!. Les articles… There are « DEUX » articles that can show that something is plural. Les = the Les ciseaux,
Le niveau de vie des étudiants en Europe The standard of living of the students in Europe Observatoire de la vie étudiante / France Padoue Ronan.
PwCs Academy Entretien de recrutement Bien préparer et mener un entretien de recrutement 04 novembre
Using the present subjunctive mood in French
Core Module 9 Family and Community Engagement Association des conseils scolaires des écoles publiques de lOntario (ACÉPO) Association franco-ontarienne.
EUROPEAN ASSOCIATION OF DEVELOPMENT RESEARCH AND TRAINING INSTITUTES ASSOCIATION EUROPÉENNE DES INSTITUTS DE RECHERCHE ET DE FORMATION EN MATIÈRE DE DÉVELOPPEMENT.
Sexuality as a rights-claiming object and the politics of humanitarianism LAMES (Laboratoire méditerranéen de sociologie) at Maison Méditerranéenne des.
AFNOR NF Z – "Online Consumer Reviews
28th Conference of Directors of Paying agencies Namur, 27 to 29 October 2010 The Belgian Presidency of the Council of the European Union Workshop 2 : Control.
Indefinite articles, plural of nouns
Mme Sheeler. AVOIR = to have J ai nous avons Tu as vous avez Il a ils ont Elle a elles ont On a.
Mardi 20 Novembre 2012 Recap I can
ALAI 2001, New York The protection of technological measures and the exceptions and limitations to copyright M e François Lajeunesse Avocat principal/Senior.
1 La promotion de la santé ancrée dans la loi Le mandat de Promotion Santé Suisse est ancré dans la loi fédérale du 18 mars 1994 sur lassurance maladie.
On-line resource materials for policy making Ex-Ante Carbon-balance Tool Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, FAO Apprendre à utiliser.
Bienvenue à la classe de français!
Observations from the International Drug Policy Consortium JAMIE BRIDGE SENIOR POLICY AND OPERATIONS MANAGER AU CONFERENCE OF MINISTERS OF DRUG CONTROL.
140 ans Dune entreprise familiale à… Une famille dentreprises.
Youth Involvement - revitalising the Scout Method Participation des jeunes - revitaliser la méthode scoute.
Societas Europaea Employee involvement Implication des travailleurs Beteiligung der Arbeitnehmer Jean-Claude Le Douaron ASE-ETUCO-EGA.
Le 14 octobre Léchauffement: Complétez. 1. Un _______ à main 2. Une place _______ fenêtre 3. Le _______ de sécurité 4. Une __________ de lair 5. Le personnel.
Laboratoire de Bioinformatique des Génomes et des Réseaux Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgique Introduction Statistics.
L’ensemble microcanonique
Politiques d’information Le Pentagone, les médias et la guerre en Irak
La pratique factuelle Années 90 un concept médical visant à optimiser les décisions cliniques face aux soins des patients Aujourdhui un concept évolutif,
29e CONFÉRENCE INTERNATIONALE DES COMMISSAIRES À LA PROTECTION DES DONNÉES ET DE LA VIE PRIVÉE 29 th INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE OF DATA PROTECTION AND PRIVACY.
QU’EST-CE QUE TU FAIS?.
Les lycées. Sixth form is compulsory in France so it is really important to choose the right one. Look carefully at the information about colleges and.
Les normes: Communication 1.2 Comparisons 4.2 La question essentielle: What is the formula for conjugating -RE verbs and what are some of these verbs?
Security Council Deadlock Deadlock - great powers, use of veto Two problems - resolutions and execution Need to effectively maintain peace How? Deadlock.
T HE VERB FAIRE A very versatile irregular verb You can DO the right thing by MAKING the conjugations of this verb fit the subject!
Donnez l’heure “Time”… it’s a ticking!.
Starter Can you remember the phonics you have already practised in Le petit chaperon rouge? We practised the sounds.
Employment Policies. an Azorean story...
Memorandum to the President of the United States Re: Application of Treaties and Laws to al Qaeda And Taliban Detainees US Department of Justice Office.
INDICATOR DEFINITION An indicator describes the manifestation of a process of change resulting from the pursuit of an action. Un indicateur décrit la manifestation.
6 Le verbe Faire Les normes: –Communications 1.2: Understanding the written and spoken language –Comparisons 4.1: Understanding language through comparisons.
The political ecnomy of tourism development in Tolagnaro (Madagascar) Utilization of natural resources in the struggle against poverty Bruno Sarrasin Professeur.
The new or evolving “access right” Le nouveau “droit d’accès aux oeuvres” Alain Strowel Professeur Facultés Saint-Louis et Université de Liège, Avocat,
Fabio Bortolotti THE PERSPECTIVE OF AN ARBITRATOR LE POINT DE VUE D’UN ARBITRE Production of documents – Direct examination and cross examination Production.
Orbitales “s” Figure:
Qui and que can both be translated as ‘that’ or ‘which’ or ‘who’. They are called relative pronouns because the relate back to a noun which has been mentioned.
Plain Language Movement  Apparu au début des années 1970 aux Etats-Unis.  Plain language v. legalese.  Simplifier les documents juridiques destinés.
Cliquez et modifiez le titre Cliquez pour modifier les styles du texte du masque – Deuxième niveau Troisième niveau – Quatrième niveau » Cinquième niveau.
© Copyright Showeet.com S OCIAL M EDIA T HINKING.
La norme Iso26000 La norme ISO définit comment les organisations peuvent et doivent contribuer au développement durable. Elle est publiée depuis.
LES MODULES PLAN DE DEVELOPPEMENT PERSONNEL LEADERSHIP ART ORATOIRE.
English for Lawyers IV REVISION
Transcription de la présentation:

CRIMINALIZING THE BREACHES OF THE CARDINAL PRINCIPLES OF HUMANITARIAN LAW AND THE REBIRTH OF INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL LAW Presentation of Lyne Calder, Giulia Soldan and Chantal Staehelin L‘Evolution du droit international du maintien de la paix, Prof. Dupuy 25 November 2010

OUTLINE Contexte historique Legal basis for the creation of the ICTY Contribution of the ICTY to the development of International Humanitarian Law Penser plus loin...

1. CONTEXTE HISTORIQUE Contexte politique de la création du TPIY : début des années ’90 Fin de la guerre froide (1989)– intervention en Iraq (1990-1991) Intervention en Somalie (à partir d’avril 1992) Nécessité d’intervenir dans les Balkans: théâtre d’un “nouvel Holocaust” Importance des médias occidentaux

Contexte juridique Tribunaux militaires internationaux de Nuremberg et Tokyo (1945) Convention sur la prévention et répression du crime de génocide (1948) Développement de la doctrine des droits de l’homme (à partir du 1945) et des normes impératives du droit international (Convention de Vienne sur le droit des traités 1969) Travaux de la Commission de droit international Code des crimes contre la paix et la sécurité de l’humanité (1991, 1996) Projet de Statut d’une cour pénale internationale (1990, 1994) Projet d’article sur la Responsabilité de l’État pour fait internationalement illicite (1ère version : 1996) Crime de l’État Responsabilité collective

2. LEGAL BASIS FOR THE CREATION OF THE ICTY “ Expressing once again its grave alarm at continuing reports of widespread violations of international humanitarian law occurring within the territory of the former Yugoslavia and especially in Bosnia and Herzegovina, including reports of mass killings and the continuance of the practice of “ethnic cleansing”, UNSC Resolution 780 (1992): established a Commission of Experts “to examine and analyse the information submitted … with a view to providing the Secretary-General its conclusions on the evidence of grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions and other violations of international humanitarian law” UNSC Resolution 808 (1993): decides on the establishment of an international tribunal to prosecute persons responsible for serious violations of IHL, requests the Secretary-General to submit a report on “all aspects of the matter, including specific proposals” UNSC Resolution 827 (1993): “Acting under Chapter VII of the Charter of the United Nations” accepts the Statute of the International Tribunal, decides all State shall cooperate fully with the International Tribunal and its organs

“ The Security Council is thus subjected to certain constitutional limitations, however broad its powers under the constitution may be. Those powers cannot, in any case, go beyond the limits of the jurisdiction of the Organization at large, not to mention other specific limitations or those which may derive from the internal division of power within the Organization. In any case, neither the text nor the spirit of the Charter conceives of the Security Council as legibus solutus (unbound by law). ” Prosecutor v Dusko Tadic, Decision on the Defence Motion for Interlocutory Appeal on Jurisdiction, 2 October 1995, § 28

Is Chapter VII greater than the sum of its parts?

Article 39 The Security Council shall determine the existence of any threat to the peace, breach of the peace, or act of aggression and shall make recommendations, or decide what measures shall be taken in accordance with Articles 41 and 42, to maintain or restore international peace and security.

Article 41 The Security Council may decide what measures not involving the use of armed force are to be employed to give effect to its decisions, and it may call upon the Members of the United Nations to apply such measures. These may include complete or partial interruption of economic relations and of rail, sea, air, postal, telegraphic, radio, and other means of communication, and the severance of diplomatic relations

Does the ICTY satisfy the requirement that a tribunal must be “established by law”? Required by articles 14 ICCPR, 6(1) ECHR, 8(1) ACHR and therefore a general principle of law as recognised by civilised nations

Jurisdiction of the ICTY according to its Statute: 3. CONTRIBUTION OF THE ICTY TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW Jurisdiction of the ICTY according to its Statute: Grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 (Art. 2) Violations of the laws and customs of war (Art. 3) Genocide (Art. 4) Crimes against humanity (Art. 5)

3. CONTRIBUTION OF THE ICTY TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW Report of the Secretary-General on the establishment of the ICTY, 3 May 1993, § 34: “The application of the principle nullum crimen sine lege requires that the international tribunal should apply rules of international humanitarian law which are beyond any doubt part of customary international law so that the problem of adherence of some but not all States to specific conventions does not arise.”

3. CONTRIBUTION OF THE ICTY TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW Case law can have important effects on the development of IL insofar as it: interprets and clarifies existing custom and identifies new emergent custom addresses legal lacunae, adds flesh to the bare bones of treaty provisions or to broad legal concepts, e.g. proportionality

3. CONTRIBUTION OF THE ICTY TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW

Custom in non-international armed conflicts 3. CONTRIBUTION OF THE ICTY TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW War Crimes: Custom in non-international armed conflicts The Question of criminalization Evidence for custom cited by the Tadic case: Military manuals of a couple of countries Criminal code of the Social Federal Republic of Yugoslavia Security Council Resolutions

4. WHAT NEXT? Proliferation of international and internationalised tribunals: International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (1993) International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (1994) The International Criminal Court (Statute adopted 1998, ratified 2002) Special Court for Sierra Leone (2002) Cambodia Tribunal (∼2006) Special Tribunal for Lebanon (2009)

LA JUSTICE PÉNALE INTERNATIONALE COMME INSTRUMENT DE PROMOTION DE LA PAIX? Élargissement des mandats des tribunaux : non seulement en vue de punir mais aussi avec le but de rétablir la paix, réconcilier la société, établir la « vérité » … La justice pénale internationale intervenant au cours du conflit ou seulement après le conflit