RIEDP PDG Telecon8 – 24 April 2015 RIEDP DM Foundations Document Review Référence – Date : E2Cxxxx du RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data.  Introduction  Summary of past events  Approval of DG2 members  Review of RIEDP DM Foundations Document  AOB  Conclusion Agenda RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Web connection information  Friday, 24 April 2015  4:30 PM France, 3:30 PM UK, 10:30 AM ET, 7:30 AM PT   Tel  Germany:  France:  Netherlands:  United Kingdom:  United States:  Connection code: #  Phone numbers for other countries are also available  Introduction Web connection information RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Summary of Past Events RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Current status Summary of past events Previous Meetings  F13 SIW KickOff  Telecon1 15/11/2013  IITSEC'13 Day1, Day2  Telecon2 29/01/14 - Telecon3 16/07/14  Fall SIW 2014  Telecon4 29/10/ Telecon5 28/01/ Telecon6 16/03/2015  Telecon7 08/04/2015 Approval of Telecon7 Notes  Approval of DG2 members list All Notes posted on RIEDP Library RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 XL Notes

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. DG principles Check Consistency Find PDG Consensus Approve within PDG Towards Balloting - Reference Doc - Copyrights Define for Doc1 & 2 : - Doc Headlines - Sections principles - Guidances - Wording by DGM - Cross Reviews - Wording by DGM - Cross Reviews Identify Use Draft Doc1 Draft Doc2 Recommandations V0 Doc1 & 2 for PDG approval V1 Doc1 & 2 for balloting § allocation § wording - Flesh out Doc 1 - Find DGM consensus - Align with Doc 2 - Flesh out Doc 2 - Find DGM consensus - Align with Doc 1 § allocation § wording Doc 1 = RIEDP Data Model Foundations (RPM+RADM) Doc 2 = RIEDP Detailled Features Description

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. BAILEYGrantUK MoDUK CASTANERGilbertSOGITECFR COGMANJackDATASIMUK COXRobPEO STRI / RDGUSA ENOCHIANDavidAFMCUSA FAULKMarkLEIDOSUSA FOLEYPaulDOD Terrain MSEA NGAUSA HUMPHRIESRolandXPI SimulationUK IGARZAJean-LouisAntycip Simulation FranceFR MACCHIWarrenABAMISUSA MAMAGHANIFaridSEDRISUSA MARROULanceLEIDOSUSA MOORERonaldLEIDOSUSA PEELEGregARAUSA REIFAndreasBwBGER ROBBINSBruce US Army/PEO STRI/OneSAFUSA SCRUDDERRoyUniv TexasUSA SIEGFRIEDRobertADITERNAGER TABOURETYannTT&SFRA Approval of DG2 members RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 List (except Chair & Vice Chair) USA11 UK3 FRA3 GER2

RIEDP Data Model Foundations RPM & RADM RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. RIEDP Data Model Foundations Previous step Population of the RIEDP DM Foundations  Based on  PN !  Existing Description from Final Report  Complement from SE Core Documentation (RPM)  Elements From NPSI and AFCD  Elements From Sogitec Sindbad  Who ?  DG 2 : Gilbert as Co-DGE – Other Co-DGE Farid  Status  Draft 0.9 submitted to review on Wednesday 11 March  Telecon 6 and 7  Some comments  New comments since then RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. From the inception of RIEDP, confirmed by RIEDP SG and PN  …  Two products  Product 1 (Foundations) is a Guidance Product 2 (Attributes) is a Standard  The initial goal of RIEDP is to ensure the immediate environmental data requirements and needs of the Aircrew Training and Mission Rehearsal (ATMR) community, which also involves ground-based applications and simulations through close air support, are addressed. However, the other application domains of the M&S community will see positive impact from RIEDP.  The objective of this PDG is the harmonization of environmental data representations and generation processes at a level after the source data stage but before the runtime/proprietary stage … Possible deviations, to be controled ! Scope and principles of RIEDP as in PN RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 PN

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. RIEDP Data Model Foundations Headlines RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. What’s New in the RPM? RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Food for thought  § 1 to Introduction, Background, goals, Reference, Definitions,…  § RPM :  Stages & Tasks - Notion of « Database » (IT sense) – Reuse at various stages  Add a « RIEDP Export » Task within each Stage ?  § 4.3 RADM  Structure : Repository, Catalog, DB, Library, Tiles, Layers, Attributes  to be improved  Formats ?  Where to set the limit between Document 1 and Document 2  Attribution, Tables, and Meta Data  Definition of RIEDP profiles for each Layer standard  GeoTIFF, Shape file, JPEG2K …  Identification of what is specific in th use of these standards in RIEDP –Idem as GeoTiff vs TIFF  Next § Informal Review of RIEDP DM Foundations RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Comments from Telecon participants  Identified Reviewers  Warren MacchiTelecon6  Jack CogmanTelecon6  Roy21 April  Lance23 April  Paul Foleypending  Yann Tabouretpending  Ron?  David Graham?  USAF ?  NAVAIR ? Informal Reviews of RIEDP DM Foundations RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 Doc as posted Doc as posted Roy+ WM+ JC Roy+ WM+ JC Lance

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Editorial  Warren, Jack, Roy, Paul, Lance  intro, Titles depth, inconsistency Diagr vs text, position of RPM detailed view, General  Warren, Roy, Paul, Lance  Shall vs Should ; Guidance vs Specification ; Conformance  Roy, Lance  Scope of RIEDP (> Air) ; Scope of RPM (incl. Runtime? incl Specialized? )  Paul  Production vs generation ; Database vs representation  Lance  Targeted audience / Level of detail for explanations / Ref to 2 nd product; Technical  Next slide Review of comments and contributions RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 Preview of latest RADM Preview of latest RADM

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Technical  Warren  Which Library ; Gaming area ;  Roy  Library (Shared or not); Catalog (one vs multiple); RIEDP Formats;  Additional Data to be aligned; Intensification vs Additional Data;  Same formats in all stages; RIEDP Profile; dataset and database;  changes to RADM; Data product; TINs excluded  Lance  RIEDP Formats / Internal vs export formats; Additional Data & Base line;  List of input formats, Ref to EDS; 3D moving models not in scope ;  Sub tasks in parallel or not; Restrictive Attribute dictionary,  Intensification; feature mapping,  procedural generation; RTP - run from source systems Review of comments and contributions RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 Preview of latest RADM Preview of latest RADM

RIEDP Detailed Features Description RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. RIEDP Detailed Features Description Approach  During Telecon2, it was agreed that it was currently difficult to go into high detail on DG3 (Attribution subject) before the RADM is sufficiently stabilized.  However, preliminary discussion was held during Telecon3 to analyze possible approaches.  Core Team work current results :  DG3 has now an impact on DG2  Attribution RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. RIEDP Detailed Features Description Approach Process  Assess available Dictionaries and select the most suitable as the RIEDP reference dictionary  Check what is available and what is missing in these dictionnaries  Identify required extensions or additions to the dictionary  Identify the required collection of Features (classes) and Attributes needed for RIEDP  Define what is mandatory and what is optional  Define how this collection can be described with the reference dictionary  Identify mappings between RIEDP Attributions and those used by the initiatives/users  This process will be incremental (for initialization and as for updates), it is important to define a flexible way of characterizing the underlying “Data model” of the attribution Features and Attributes. RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. RIEDP Detailed Features Description Next step Initialization of the RIEDP DFD  Based on  ???  Who ?  DG 3  Volunteers ?  Schedule  End of 2014  Status during IITSEC RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Next Events RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Next Events ITEC 2015  SISO Seminar  RIEDP Brief – Monday 27 April at ITEC venue - Prague  RIEDP Meeting  Tuesday 28 April 13h00 – Hotel Duo – Prague  Intention to participate  JLG and Andreas Reif  Any other participant ? Gilbert remotely, TT&S  Those who cannot : Farid, Rob, Roy, Robert, … Telecon 9  To be held during Week ?Date to be agreed RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Action Items RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Action Items Attendance RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

AOB RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. AOB ?? RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Conclusion RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Conclusion During Session RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Backup RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Runtime DB Runtime DB Runtime DB Runtime DB Runtime DB Runtime DB Specialized Source Data Sets Specialized Source Data Sets Specialized Source Data Sets Specialized Source Data Sets SE Core - Shareable Data : Three steps RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 N Steps Process Cleaned Source Data Sets Cleaned Source Data Sets Intensified Source Data Sets Intensified Source Data Sets Confederate Specialized Source Data Sets Confederate Specialized Source Data Sets Runtime DB Runtime DB Arc GISArc GIS + Plugin Terravista, Terratools, VBS2 Requirements : -Areas -Insets -LOD Arc GIS + Plugin 70 % No Tiling Source : - Vectors - Imagery - Elevation - 3D Models Applications : - Training - Mission Rehearsal Quality Check - Improvement 80 % ?90 % ? n % ? LOD : -1: 250K -1: 50K -1: 25K -1.12,5K Geography SimulationMachine Various Targets Imagery used to extract featuresSynthetic Imagery Scattering Features Adapted consistent Data Sets

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Database Generation eCognition ArcGIS stereo analyst MERLIN SimSys Vector data textures, plan imagery ERDAS Imagine LPS DSM ortho imagery DSM Ortho imagery (R,G,B,Nir; hyperspectral) data base ERDAS IMAGINE, LPSPhotogrammetry tool eCognitionClassification tool MERLINDGBS ArcGIS stereo analyst3D-extraction tool New input from BwB (German MOD) German example of DB Generation process RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Improvement of the RADM  The RADM is the consolidated abstraction of existing data elements and their relationship found in databases produced for use in Aircrew Mission Training and similar applications (mainly air and some aspects of ground forces (for SAF)).  One use of the RADM is providing a way to express the data at the end of each stage in the RPM  At the end of each of these stages, not all the data that is needed in the final database may be available or present, but the RADM can still be used to identify the data elements at that point in the process, although some of the elements in the RADM will be empty or unpopulated.  The main goal of the RADM, however, is to provide a model for the entirety of the data that would be found at the end of the database generation process, just prior to the runtime database creation stage. RIEDP Data Model Foundations New step RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8

Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data. Reference Abstract Data Model RIEDP-PDG - Telecon8 Convergence Common format Variability